(I)ncredibly (C)omplicated (J)argon - Croatia v Serbia

Like Judge Peter Tomka
Monday, February 9, 2015 - 12:21

Photo: Judge Peter Tomka making his way through the sizeable judgment

By Niklas Jakobsson

After two hours of mens rea, dolus specialis and actus reus, the International Court of Justice finally dismissed a claim and counter-claim of genocide between Serbia and Croatia. Judge Peter Tomka soldiered doggedly through the judgment which in its full printed form exceeded 700 pages. With the world able to watch the judgment unfolding live via webcast, the international justice Twitter circle spent hours going through every sentence of the decision.

As Judge Tomka wrapped up the judgment with a final sip of juice, it became clear that neither Serbs nor Croats were any nearer  closure on this delicate issue that has haunted them for the last two decades. In fact, some people argue that the court’s decision and the long process were only of benefit to a few individuals.

The decision by the judges to dismiss both cases boiled down in the end to both parties inability to prove the mental aspect of genocide. Without getting too technical, neither side proved the other party’s intent to destroy a group in full or in part. But for some people, the message from the judges was a lot simpler than that.

Picking up on the same train of thought, Andrea Oskari Rossini came to a similar conclusion 

“Serbia and Croatia are invited to "cooperate", in particular to address the issue of people still missing and to provide "adequate compensation to the victims", thus consolidating "peace and stability in the region". After 16 years, the courts returned the ball to the parties.”

International law largely relies on previous decisions in future cases. Therefore the ICJ had an opportunity to establish jurisprudence for cases to come. Instead, this decade-and-a-half long legal process seemingly taught us only one thing about the court.

But in what many called an unsurprising judgment, the devil (or the devilish surprise) was still in the detail. In an article by Janet Anderson for Justice Hub, Oliver Ribbelink at the TMC Asser Institute found the level of detail in the judgment the most surprising.

“I found it surprising that they went into so much detail on the actual events – what happened here and what happened there. Many place names and municipalities have been mentioned by the Court. And they relied very much on the Yugoslavia Tribunal jurisprudence. That tribunal has dealt with so many of these issues.”

But the thing that might be the most controversial could, according to some, be published by both countries.

At the end of the day all that seems clear that people left the court knowing roughly the same about the legal implication of genocide as they did two hours earlier.

 

So…

  • Does the ICJ take too long to make a judgment?
  •  What will be the impact of the judgment on the relationship between Croatia and Serbia?
  • Isn’t the proof of acts of genocide enough to prove genocide?

Lead image: Judge Peter Tomka (Photo: UN Photo/CIJ-ICJ/Frank van Beek)

The Weekly Hubble features the most popular or controversial international justice story of the past week and reactions on social media to the news. 

Like
Anonymous
David D Y Choi

This is David D Y Choi, who has been placed at limited status as usual ~ Between 2001 and 2013, joined work sites were recorded by at least 45, mostly at SoC projects from conflict zones up to war zone repeatedly. In reality, further case of contracted basis work opportunity has not given at all, as long as has shown, not to cooperate action, toward repeated pre-framed sites.

Believing that, there, still, there is a reliable settlement site is in existence under the sky. David D Y Choi duly@gmx.com, dulywork@hushmail.com cdyera@yandex.com ( in case duly@gmx.com e-mail system is blocked ) Tel. : +82-19-378-4105 Personal URL : http://www.cdyera.wordpress.com On the bottom of Personal URL, linked images are eligible, hand written images, between Apr. 2015 and Feb. 2016. ====

Friday, October 13, 2017 - 05:49
Anonymous
David D Y Choi

Believing that, there, still, a reliable settlement site is in existence under the sky. Upon receiving of positive notice, will be reached at designated site within a few days. Between 2001 and 2013, joined work sites were recorded by at least 45, from SoC projects up to conflict zones. My potential skills would be key asset toward your region.

David D Y Choi duly@gmx.com, dulywork@hushmail.com Tel. : +82-19-378-4105 Personal URL : http://www.cdyera.wordpress.com On the bottom of Personal URL, linked images are eligible, hand written images, between Apr. 2015 and Feb. 2016.

Saturday, August 5, 2017 - 05:12
Anonymous
David D Y Choi

This is David D Y Choi again From his limited as usual.

Since Dec. 2007, I have supported my mother up to Feb. 2016 After her brain surgery, on the date of Dec 23, 2007.

Over the 8 years, I did my best from mother’s surgery date up to 2nd, 3rd, 4th of transferring of medical institute under the current system of limit of three months to be hospitalized.

Meanwhile, At the 4th Medial institute, I could have free time as the its site was not forced me to transfer mother’s hospital site. This made be long stay at 4th site between 2008 and 2015.

Meanwhile, As the given condition was known as ‘Gov. Sanction’ basis on local TV forum in Vienna, Austria On the date of April 14, 2014, My financial condition is getting worse as the acquired work site has not been secure to extend. This made me a lot of record, at least 45 sites as the joining work sites in homeland, S Korea.

In reality, I could not acquire any of additional work opportunity since Aug 2013. This made me send tons of messages toward Europe. Among the e-mail receivers, there, one of open minded personnel urged me to apply Asylum seeker.

During April 2014, Experiencing of Asylum, at the detention center, Realizing that, given status was not secure as usual, I was the key story source and chased by local policemen inside of camp in there, Vienna. Before leading the camp, a camp representative told me, there were a lot of phone calls, per hour, whether my status, would be terminated, fly back to homeland etc.

Back to origin, In homeland, with supported by IOM bureau, I have been in the middle of limited condition as usual. No income, No job anymore, simply blocked.

Since 2014, Government, especially, Court designated representative offered me of black mail.

Moreover, I received a letter of Subpoena from Family court, Asking of ‘Summons’ on the date of June 1st 15:00, 2016.

While inquiring of special region of ‘Summons’, as the given letter is not clear, Toward court employee, via phone calling, nothing is disclosed.

On the given letter, “there is research issue, attendance is required on the date of June 1st 15:00, 2016 at the court, Research Dept. suite 702”

Wishing that, There surely is a reasonable site to settle not be suffocated to death under the Sky.

David D Y Choi duly@gmx.com or dulywork@hushmail.com Tel. : +82-19-378-4105 Personal URL : http://www.cdyera.wordpress.com On the bottom of Personal URL, liked images are eligible, hand written images, between Apr 2015 and Feb 2016.

Tuesday, May 17, 2016 - 04:48
Anonymous
David D Y Choi

To whom it may concern ; This is David D Y Choi , from his limited status as usual known as ‘Gov. Sanction’.

Personally, with experienced of SOC project, I may develop refugee related project with fresh eyes basis vision upon receiving of work opportunity for them. Myself, have experienced of Asylum during April 2014. While experiencing of Asylum, as the given status was not secure to be extended, I had to submit withdraw notice at the detention center. Looking back of its status, at refugee camp, refugee basis program should be focusing on applicants' needs. To solve the limit of refugee affairs. there required of adding fresh eyes basis vision from the object point of view. Upon receiving of any of positive notice to join at refugee related program or its development affair, I would like to join as an employee toward the reliable organization or related bureau. Any of reply would be welcomed. David D Y Choi Personal URL http://www.cdyera.wordpress.com Image Web 1) http://www.sandiegoreader.com/users/cdyera/# Image Web 2) Wikimedia Commons ; searching word ; cdyera https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Main_Page Wiki Media Commons ( 1 ~ 20 ) https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?search=cdyera&title=Special%3ASearch&go=Go&uselang=ko Wiki Media Commons ( 21~ 40 ) https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Search&limit=20&offset=20&profile=default&search=cdyera&uselang=ko Wiki Media Commons ( 41~ now up to 52 and 1 comment from web site ) https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Search&limit=20&offset=40&profile=default&search=cdyera&uselang=ko Image Web 3) http://www.kgw.com/ - your pics – channels - breaking news ( # 1~ 48 ) On the date, Dec 22. 2015, my account is disabled basis on company web site notice. Also, pre-loaded images between # 1 ~ 48, are deleted without their traces On the date, Dec 23. 2015, I am reloading action, hand written images, between # 1~ 48 at the different section at the above web site; your pics- channels - KGW community On the date, Dec 24. 2015, Reloaded images, all are deleted without their traces. Opened Personal Account is disabled as usual similar to Facebook & Twitter accounts. ==

Saturday, January 23, 2016 - 01:48
Anonymous